Naomi Weisman is the writer of Nomi's Pics and the editor of the Rambler Cafe Blog. She is a Canadian-Australian and mother of three who loves to Ramble with her dog, cook for family and friends, and laugh whenever possible.
Alan Hlad’s The Long Flight Home took our Sole Sister Ramblers Book Club Challenge on an emotional journey through World War II—one that balanced history, heart, and heroism. While reactions varied, everyone agreed that the story of homing pigeons and the people who trained them brought a unique and fascinating perspective to wartime life. It was a page-turner that inspired curiosity, compassion, and thoughtful discussion about how ordinary beings—human and animal alike—played extraordinary roles during a dark time in history.
Summary
Set in 1941 England, The Long Flight Home introduces us to Susan Shepherd, a young woman training carrier pigeons for Britain’s National Pigeon Service, and Ollie Evans, an American pilot who finds himself grounded in her world. Together, they form a bond—both romantic and patriotic—as they prepare pigeons to carry crucial messages across the Channel during Operation Columba. The novel’s epilogue jumps forward to 1996, offering a bittersweet closure that ties together love, loss, and remembrance.
Readers’ Perceptions
Many readers loved the book’s premise and appreciated learning about the surprising role pigeons played during the war. For several, this historical detail was brand-new and eye-opening. One member shared, “I did not know about Operation Columba or the idea of using homing pigeons! I was fascinated by it and grateful to have learned about it.”
However, opinions varied on the storytelling choices. Some found the final time jump from 1941 to 1996 jarring or overly sentimental, while others appreciated the closure it provided. “It was a nice ending but a bit sappy,” one Sister noted, while another admitted she “didn’t mind the big jump in years because it showed how life still goes on but memories last a lifetime.”
A couple felt “cheated” by the missing years and would have loved to see more of Susan and Ollie’s lives unfold. Yet even those who found flaws described it as a “great, well-written book” that would “make a wonderful movie.”
Themes and Reflections
The book’s central themes—sacrifice, love, resilience, and memory—resonated strongly with readers. Many reflected on the senseless suffering of war, both in history and in today’s conflicts. One member said, “It always makes me sad to read about the suffering people endured during the war… and the suffering going on now makes me so sad and mad about the bombings. War is such a waste of everything.”
Hlad’s characters serve as reminders that even in times of despair, acts of courage and tenderness can prevail. Susan and Ollie’s story humanizes the war’s enormity, while the pigeons themselves become powerful symbols of hope, loyalty, and connection—bridging distances both literal and emotional.
The love story sparked debate: some found it far-fetched but sweet; others thought it elevated the narrative by grounding it in humanity. “However far-fetched the idea of a pet pigeon carrying love notes across the Channel may be,” one reader wrote, “it was delightful to imagine it as true.”
Fact and Fiction
Readers admired how the blend of history and imagination made them more curious about real events. “It absolutely does!” one Sister said. “I love researching the factual parts of historical fiction as I’m reading—it enriches my experience.” This curiosity is one of the gifts of the genre, turning a simple story into a springboard for learning.
Final Thoughts
The Long Flight Home was widely seen as engaging, heartfelt, and thought-provoking, even if not perfect. Some found the ending too tidy, others too tragic—but all agreed it left them thinking about the resilience of people (and animals) in wartime. The novel’s ability to introduce readers to new historical details while exploring timeless themes of love and sacrifice made it a fitting and memorable choice for our book club.
As one Sister summed up beautifully:
“I was willing to overlook its flaws and just enjoy it. The creative ways the Allies worked to win the war are continually amazing to me. It left me smiling—and grateful to have shared the journey with this group.”
Learn More > Virtual Fitness and Lifestyle Challenges
Leave a comment