Funeral Planning Pauline - Just Jill Advice Column

Funeral Planning Pauline - Just Jill

Just Jill is the creation of Jill Cohen Morris. Jill is an avid rambler and married mother of two from Toronto, Canada, with a remarkable zest for life and a fabulous sense of humor. 

Dear Just Jill,

I’m a healthy sixty-four-year-old woman with no plans of dying anytime soon. What I have learned, though, in all my years, is that none of us truly knows what tomorrow will bring.

So here I am, thinking about my funeral, burial, and everything in between.

Not something I want to think about, but is there ever a good time?

I have decided I want to be buried, not cremated. Next steps? How do I choose a cemetery? When do I look at plots? Do I pick my own casket?

Then there is the funeral … Do I have specific wishes? Who speaks? What songs play? Who officiates? I don’t know!!

Do I just not care and leave it to my loved ones? I feel that’s not right. I don’t know what’s right??

I need advice from my wise Sole Sisters.

What’s a gal to do?

Sincerely,

Funeral Planning Pauline

Sole Sister Advice & Comments

  • This is a decision I’ve struggled with as well. At the moment, my instructions are to have me cremated and then plant a tree for me with my ashes buried by that tree. But I guess I want my partner and my kids to do whatever they want to with my ashes. I just feel that I should give my kids the option to have a physical place to visit my memory. It’s a tough one because everyone in my family is buried with a headstone. I have a physical place to visit if I want to. The only thing is, I only visit once or twice per year

  • When my ex-husband passed away, his wishes were to have his ashes sprinkled at a lake at a school he attended. My daughters wanted a physical location to visit him and asked for my advice. I asked, what did your dad tell you that he wanted? He didn’t say anything at the end or have anything written down, so we discussed taking some ashes to his school, and we buried some at a local cemetery with a beautiful bench. At this school’s 50th reunion, we had a service for him. What an experience for my daughters and me.

  • When I bought my flat, I got myself a will and went through all of this with my sister (no partner, no kids). It isn’t fun, but at least I know it’s done.

  • My decision was to be cremated and then for my family to travel to all the places I’ve lived in. My estate will pay for that trip. That’s the way I decided I wanted them to remember me. See the world I saw, make new memories, and take that with them.

  • Tough one. I want to be cremated as well, but so far, I have had no discussion with my family about the ashes. Having been uprooted over twenty ago, I have no idea where I want to be "laid to rest". Maybe I should have that talk with my daughters soon.

  • This is a timely question as I am sadly preparing to deal with this situation soon for my ailing mother. I want to be cremated and like the idea of being scattered in different places, but I would still like a final ‘resting’ place for visitation purposes. A dilemma. Without children and grandchildren, my husband would like that to be in his hometown, but I am not sure about that location. A tough conversation and decision for sure.

  • We experienced a very unexpected death in our family a few years ago, and there was no will, no instructions, or planning in place at all. This added a whole other level of pain and anxiety in trying to figure out wishes and deal with the estate. My husband and I had our wills in place, but this experience prompted us both to prepare a document that contains all of our personal information, bank accounts, pension info, bills that need paying, and which accounts, cremation wishes, etc.…pretty much everything! Lol! We update it each year to make sure it is current. We have also written love letters to our children and our loved ones, and they sit together in a file for the eventual day. This gives us peace of mind knowing that nobody will wonder what we want and where to start settling our affairs, and we can also leave our family with words from our heart (this was my hubby’s idea, and I thought it was really beautiful). 

  • So smart to be looking into your options now. My father started talking to me about what he had in place decades before he died: all the people he wanted me to call (friends, family, coworkers, attorney, accountant), where the safety deposit box key was, and anything else he felt was important. I was thankful that he was SO organized. The first few years of talks were not easy, but the subject matter got easier as time went on. He also had everything set and paid for - plot, casket, headstone - and it made it SO much easier for me. I could not imagine having to make those choices at the time of dealing with all the feelings that accompanied the time of his death.

  • I have told loved ones that I wish for a green burial. Those “cemeteries” are like parks with nature all around—a much more pleasant place to visit and walk around than the usual cemetery. I feel it’s up to them whether they feel the need for any kind of ceremony for closure. I do have music picked out for any get-together (some control issues at work here). 

  • I really like the idea of my estate paying for a trip or some kind of fun event, so they have one last family memory made that in some way includes me. Another thought is to have a flash drive, or whatever new technology allows, of family/friends/trips, pictures, and movie clips put together to be given after I’m gone so anyone who wants can “remember” so many more times gone by than their brains are able to retrieve.

  • I am an only child, and as such, I was responsible for handling my mother's final wishes. Sometime before she passed, she gave me a sealed envelope. In that note, she listed every detail of her funeral, from the minister to the kind of flowers she wanted. And everything was prepaid. What a wonderful gift to me.

  • I appreciate this question because I realize I have not thought about the actual funeral and where I’d like to be buried, partly because I’m unsure where it should be. I have made arrangements to keep everything up-to-date financially and for my children to know where things are. I’m in the midst of doing a revocable trust to have them avoid probate as much as possible. 

  • It's not that important to me regarding any ceremony or what happens with my ashes. I know from experience that your wishes cannot always be accommodated. My thoughts are that funerals are more for the living than the ones that passed. For that reason, I'm not going to tell my kids what to arrange other than letting my friends know that I'm gone if they don't already, and not to spend a lot on a funeral, host a party instead.

  • I’m opting for my remains to be composted rather than cremation. I feel like this is a way to help keep nourishing this beautiful world and kinder to the environment

  • Having dealt with this stuff over the last few years, one thing I have learned is that not all PREPAID funeral arrangements are the same. BE VERY CAREFUL when you make this kind of plan. I know of several people who believed everything was paid for before they passed, but the families had to come up with THOUSANDS more for various extra charges, etc. So please have a very clear contract.

  • When my parents passed, they had everything in order. I carried a card in my wallet and just called the number, and everything happened the way they had planned and prepaid for. Make your arrangements. Your kids will give you one last big thank you!!

  • Thank you for asking this great question. For me, it helps knowing my mother has thought of it all and written it down. In a difficult time, it makes things easier. So think of it this way: how can you help make things easier for your loved ones when you pass? If it's not critical to you, say it's a suggestion you like. That way, they can opt for something different without feeling guilty or carry out your wishes knowing you're happy with it. Good luck.

  • I tried to have a chat with my mum and dad a few years ago about this. They made some vague comments but didn’t feel a need to go into details - “just do what you want.” I pointed out that my sister and I (who are very different and are not close) might think different things, and it would be preferable to know what they wanted to avoid disagreements. Didn’t get anywhere with this. When Dad died, we ended up going with what Mum wanted for him, some of which I felt he would not have wanted, which made me feel uncomfortable. Mum insisted on a speech given by a leader from her church (Dad never went). This person clearly had no idea about my dad and was not well prepared (shuffling papers, repeating herself, weird statements). I felt quite upset. My son was angry at a comment about how my father “is more beautiful now”. I made him promise never to have anything similar for me!!!

  • Mum is still with us and will only say that she wants us to spend as little as possible and doesn’t want a grave/marker as she fears it will become overgrown in later generations. I rather like old neglected graves, but we will follow her wishes. I wrote Dad’s eulogy, and my sister and I and our children read it out at his funeral. It went really well, and everyone enjoyed it. I think he would have appreciated it, too. I would suggest that you have a clear discussion with any children you have about your wishes. You can be clear without being too prescriptive, whatever works for you. Personally, I want everyone dancing at mine; mum would find this disrespectful. Hopefully, she will not be around to witness it 

  • This is such an interesting quandary. I have recently started putting together a "Death Binder" that I will offer my clients. It is a place to gather ALL the information that one's executors/family will need. Thank you for putting it out there! We all need to be talking about this stuff!!

We look forward to hearing your advice in the comments!

Happy Rambling!

SSR doesn't endorse the advice or content shared in this column. Our goal is to access the wisdom of our incredible Sole Sisters. 

READ MORE > Ask Just Jill, Rambler Cafe Blog


12 comments


  • Gina Whitelaw

    I have witnessed this same quandary many times over when I was called upon to help friends and family members with the sudden loss of loved ones over several years. After these experiences, those around me started suggesting I turn this help I was giving into a business model. When we pass away, the people we love are left to make dozens of decisions – often within days. They are faced with searching for things they need for the funeral, left making decisions about what their loved one would have wanted and more. All this extra emotional and financial stress while grieving. With that in mind, the My Planned Funeral web-based app was formed. It helps the user to plan ahead and gives clarity & peace of mind to loved ones, when the time comes. You can find out more on all socials using @myplannedfuneral or go directly to myplannedfuneral.com.au to see how it may help. The way I see it is… we basically plan ahead for every other significant event in our life; births, birthdays, graduations, engagements, weddings, retirement & more but so many people are left making hasty decisions & plans at one of the MOST significant events a person can have…DEATH! With today’s technology a person’s end-of-life CAN and SHOULD be planned. The only thing we don’t know for the plan… is a date, which is even more reason of why we should have it ready at the click of a button… just in case. What a gift & legacy you can leave for your loved ones. I thank you for bringing this very hard topic to the forefront of conversation with older woman and hope you get the answers and guidance you are looking for from this post.


  • Joyce Loucks

    I am single. My partner passed away two years ago, and I have no idea where he is buried. His son refused to tell me about his passing. I knew what his wishes were, but whether his son followed through with those wishes is another question.

    My personal plan is known by my sister. My hesitation is reaching out to the people that I would like to speak at my celebration of life, I will be cremated and want to be buried with my parents back in my hometown. In that particular graveyard you can bury up to three people in the same plot. She knows some of the songs that I want but, I need to write it down and I’ve also wanted to start working on a PowerPoint of sorts. It sounds like I’m a control freak, but I feel that if it’s all organized, it takes some of the stress off of everybody else that is left behind.


  • Nancy

    I’m Catholic so it’s very important for me to have my ashes buried in a cemetery. I have checked the cost and there are many options. Good to prepare all this so my son won’t be stuck with this.


  • Julie

    Hey There! I am a funeral director licensed in a couple states and with an unofficial specialty in green burials and composting. There absolutely are more environmentally gentle options, if that is appealing. So here’s my professional advice:
    1.) absolutely preplan in any way that’s right for you. It is fantastic and healthy for you to even just think about this stuff.
    2.) I always recommend family owned cemeteries and funeral homes, if you can find one that feels right. Ask around, as a starting place, to see if one feels better than others. If you are part of a religious or cultural group that can be a great place to start. Alternatively, drive through some cemeteries, see if they seem well maintained and looked after, or even if they just feel nice.
    3.) think about what kind of burial you want. Does a “traditional” service feel like the thing? Open casket, maybe a metal or wooden casket with a fancy interior, church or chapel service, people at the graveside… you can have clergy speak or not, depending…
    4.) you can go deep down the rabbit hole of this stuff, but ask questions, look around, talk to people. Eventually you’ll find what feels right. Know that you can change your mind if you do choose something now, at least until you can’t. 😬
    5.) if you are in a comfortable place to prepay I recommend looking into it. It is NEVER required, to my knowledge, but double check. As a rule, the biggest reasons to prepay are a.) so your survivors doesn’t have the expense or any doubts of what you’d like and b.) generally speaking the cost of nearly all expenses are guaranteed. Since you’re not going anywhere any time soon this means it doesn’t matter how much the funeral home and cemetery fees increase before you….need them. :-) They should still be covered when you do.
    6.) few if any states require embalming. Consider if embalming feels right for you. It is invasive, aggressively chemical, and does not last forever. That said, it is exactly right for many people. Just think on it and check laws.
    7.) this is the most important thing, and for every single person who glances at this. Make sure you have legally authorized or are fully comfortable with the who is in charge of your arrangements after you pass. Even if you preplan and prepay there will likely be requirements for a specific survivor to finalize those arrangements. It is usually your legal next of kin, but not everyone has that, or maybe that person isn’t the right choice. Family can be complicated. In every state there is a free document available that will legally state who you authorize to handle healthcare decisions if you’re not able and/or who you authorize to complete arrangements after you die. If you take one thing from this rambling comment, please look into this and have one accessible and known about. It is a very big deal.

    Sorry for the novel, but I hope this helps! L’Chaim! (To life!)

    Julie


  • Colmac

    I am 59thos year and so many things occurring it’s good at any age to have these conversations as life happens all the time . At 50 I purchase the booklet entitled ( My Final wishes,Everything you need to know when am gone), I found that outline beautiful and easy to follow , I believe you trust one person so they know the basic plan but leave some of the details for your love ones as they need to go through that process too .
    Cause, death is always a bitter pill to swallow.


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.