Naomi Weisman is the writer and editor of Nomi's Pics in our Rambler Café Blog. She is a Canadian-Australian and mother of three who loves to ramble with her dog, cook for family and friends, and laugh whenever possible.
Our Book Club Challenge this month has brought us to The Invisible Hour by Alice Hoffman, a compelling and intricate tale that weaves together historical fiction, fantasy, and themes of self-reliance. The novel deftly combines the timeless themes of The Scarlet Letter with a modern-day narrative, taking readers on a journey of heartbreak, time travel, and a quest for freedom. Below, we've gathered a mix of thoughts and reflections from all of you, as we explore this novel in-depth.
The Concept of Time Travel & Intertextuality
Several members expressed excitement about how The Invisible Hour combines elements of The Scarlet Letter and uses time travel to deepen the story. The protagonist, Mia Jacob, is trapped in a patriarchal cult but finds solace and strength in the works of Nathaniel Hawthorne, especially The Scarlet Letter. Her connection to the novel is magical, as it transports her to 1837 Salem, where she meets Hawthorne himself.
One of our members summed up the time travel aspect beautifully:
"I loved the time travel as well! I saw signs of it in the foreword, but using time travel as part of her safety as well as love was genius! Loved this book."
This blending of historical fiction and fantasy creates a sense of urgency and mystery, making the characters' experiences feel both timeless and universal. The idea that Mia could influence the creation of The Scarlet Letter itself—a book that is almost a mirror of her life—is intriguing and thought-provoking.
The Power of Books and the Act of Reading
A recurring theme throughout the novel is the life-changing power of reading. Confined by the rigid rules of her cult, Mia finds freedom through the books she reads. As one member noted, the idea of reading a book within a book is incredibly satisfying:
"I just love to read books within a book. This style of fiction feels like a reimagined journey with characters I am already familiar with. It's almost like a new adventure with old friends."
In The Invisible Hour, Mia's deep connection to The Scarlet Letter mirrors the idea that books have the power to transport us, offer new perspectives, and even shape the future. The novel underscores how literature can serve as both a mirror and a window, allowing us to connect with others while also discovering ourselves.
Mia’s Strength and Self-Discovery
Mia's character development is central to the novel, and several of you found her journey of self-reliance and transformation powerful. The prologue sets the stage for Mia's inner strength and determination as she navigates her escape from the cult. As one member mentioned, Mia’s growth is symbolic of a universal truth:
“In every fairy tale, the girl who is saved is the one who rescues herself."
This sentiment is echoed throughout the novel as Mia must navigate the complexities of love, fate, and autonomy. Her ability to save herself rather than rely on outside forces is a message of empowerment. The novel questions how women’s stories have often been written by others and emphasizes that, in the end, it is the woman who must save herself.
Themes of Oppression and Liberation
Mia’s life in the cult and her eventual escape is a commentary on the ways in which women have been oppressed throughout history. Many of you resonated with this part of the story, especially those of us who have faced similar struggles. One member shared:
"This resonated with me as I was once married to a charming but controlling narcissist and did what I had to do to escape. Left it all to be free."
The contrast between the idyllic yet stifling life on the farm and the oppressive reality of Mia’s situation creates a powerful commentary on freedom and choice. It also highlights how personal courage and inner strength can lead to liberation, even in the most confining circumstances.
Character Development and Mixed Reactions
While many of us loved the novel’s intricate weaving of historical and fantastical elements, others had mixed reactions. Some felt frustrated by unanswered questions or found the beginning predictable:
"The plot line about the rules in the 'Community,' aka cult, was fairly predictable and has been told before."
For some, Mia's intense love of The Scarlet Letter felt somewhat out of place, especially given how many of us find Hawthorne’s novel challenging to read. However, as another member pointed out, these elements did come together more clearly as the novel progressed, especially once the fantasy and time travel elements became more prominent.
"I actually appreciated The Scarlet Letter more after finishing The Invisible Hour. Indeed, I am now more curious about Nathaniel Hawthorne and his work."
There was a consensus that the blending of fantasy, time travel, and historical fiction might not appeal to everyone, especially if you're not a fan of that genre. Still, there was admiration for the underlying message of self-reliance and personal empowerment that permeated the novel.
Favorite Quotes and Themes
Some members shared quotes that resonated with them:
"Sometimes, when you read a book, it's as if you were reading the story of your own life. That was what happened to me. I woke up when I read the first page. I saw who I was and who I could be."
“Real life is unbelievable. Souls are snatched away from us, flesh and blood turn to dust, people you love betray you, and men go to war over nothing. It’s all preposterous. That’s why we have novels. To make sense of things.”
These quotes echo the transformative power of literature — a key theme in the book. As Mia struggles to find her way out of an oppressive world, books and reading become the key to her survival and growth.
Exploring Ivy’s "West of the Moon"
The concept of “West of the Moon,” which Ivy uses to describe her past, is rich with meaning. This phrase reflects a liminal space, a place that hovers between life and death, light and dark. One member shared a resonant interpretation from an old Norwegian tale called East of the Sun and West of the Moon:
“'East of the sun and west of the moon' is the place where the sun is eternally sinking in the west, and the moon is eternally rising in the east. It is the place that is forever in the moment before darkness. As such, it symbolizes the nearness of death, a place of crisis from which one will go either west toward the sun and life or east toward the moon and death."
This phrase captures the sense of both hopelessness and possibility that defines Ivy’s character—and, by extension, the struggles of all women seeking to break free from physical, emotional, or societal constraints.
Final Thoughts
The Invisible Hour was a polarizing read for many of us, but there is no denying its depth and complexity. Whether you loved it for its magical realism, time travel, and empowerment, or struggled with its fantasy elements, the novel raises important questions about literature’s power, self-reliance, and the ways women’s stories are told. Alice Hoffman has created a narrative that invites readers to think about the connection between the past and present, love and loss, and ultimately, how we can save ourselves.
Happy reading, everyone!
Learn More > Ramblers' Fitness and Lifestyle Challenges
