Naomi Weisman is the writer and editor of Nomi's Pics in our Rambler Café Blog. She is a Canadian-Australian and mother of three who loves to ramble with her dog, cook for family and friends, and laugh whenever possible.
When a book makes its way into our hands and grips us immediately, we know we’re onto something special. Many of us admitted we wouldn’t have picked up The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek on our own, yet it turned out to be one of those rare novels that stretches us—in perspective, in empathy, and in knowledge.
This novel did more than entertain; it educated, challenged, and deeply moved us. It brought to life a forgotten piece of American history, introduced us to a fierce and unforgettable heroine, and opened the door to important conversations about race, resilience, identity, and the power of literacy.
Summary:
Set in 1930s Kentucky during the Great Depression, The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek by Kim Michele Richardson, tells the story of Cussy Mary Carter, a young woman who works for the Pack Horse Library Project—delivering books to remote Appalachian communities on muleback.
But Cussy is no ordinary librarian. She’s one of the last remaining "Blue People" of Kentucky, a genetic condition (methemoglobinemia) that causes her skin to appear blue. This difference makes her a target for cruelty, suspicion, and exclusion in a deeply segregated and classist society.
Despite this, Cussy is determined to bring hope and education to people who have been forgotten by mainstream society. As she travels through rough terrain and tougher social barriers, she not only delivers books—she delivers dignity, connection, and possibility.
Reader Perceptions:
Several members were moved by how the novel challenged assumptions through a lens rarely explored in fiction. As one reader shared:
“I love ‘accidentally’ learning history through novels.”
We were fascinated by the story of the Blue Fugates and the Pack Horse Library—pieces of real history most of us had never encountered. The novel also sparked meaningful reflections on identity and belonging:
One reader mentioned: “I hated being different to my primary school friends... Over the years I grew into my skin colour, embraced my culture, and fell in love with my skin colour.”
Cussy’s question—“If there was a cure, would you take it?”—resonated deeply. It forced many of us to reflect on the pressure to “pass” or change in order to be accepted, particularly for those of us who’ve felt “othered” in predominantly white or monocultural environments.
Another reader noted:
“As a Jewish woman who can ‘pass’ in some circles, I’ve come to admire those who boldly express who they are, like people who wear religiously identifying clothing. Cussy’s decision not to erase herself, even at a cost, is a testament to that courage.”
We also appreciated the rich character development beyond Cussy: from the women struggling to read by lamplight to the children clinging to fairy tales in times of hunger. Books weren’t just entertainment—they were a lifeline. One reader summed it up beautifully:
“Books became windows into other worlds and allowed imaginations to travel beyond the harsh reality of the Depression.”
Themes That Stood Out:
Racism, Colorism, and Passing – The treatment of Cussy as “less than” because of her blue skin created powerful parallels to modern racism. One member reflected:
“It made me sad to think how little our world has changed since the time the novel was set.”
Literacy as Liberation – We saw books being used not just to educate, but to empower, especially women. From practical cookbooks to escapist fairy tales, every book Cussy delivered was a small rebellion against ignorance and despair.
Strength in the Face of Prejudice – Cussy’s quiet resilience, her refusal to accept shame or isolation, and her ability to find joy in service deeply resonated with readers. Despite losing a child, being ostracized, and facing unjust laws, she perseveres.
Love and Laws – Her relationship with Jackson challenged societal taboos and underscored how love must sometimes stand in defiance of unjust systems. Even though anti-miscegenation laws are gone, the subtle biases they represent still echo today.
Pride and Poverty – Several readers were struck by the complex pride of the Kentucky hill folk:
“They lived in abject poverty yet were too proud to accept handouts... it makes us think about the best ways to support people without compromising their dignity.”
Notable Quotes We Carried With Us:
“I never understood why other people thought my colour, any colour, needed fixing.”
A defining line that confronts the core issue of identity and societal rejection.
“Bring me new words when we meet again so I know the book and brain ain’t gathering dust.”
A joyful reminder of the lifelong value of reading and learning.
“I’m not a real librarian, but I’m a real book woman.”
A reminder that purpose and passion are not always bestowed by title or degree—they are earned through courage, service, and love.
Conclusion:
The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek reminded us why we love being part of this book club. It took us to a time and place we didn’t know, introduced us to a heroine we won’t forget, and invited us to reflect—on ourselves, on history, and on how far we still have to go.
As one member wrote:
“I love this book club ❤️! Thanks for broadening my reading list and reigniting my passion for reading.”
Cussy’s story—quiet, brave, book-laden—delivered more than fiction. It delivered empathy. And for that, we’re grateful.
Learn More > Virtual Fitness and Lifestyle Challenges
Leave a comment